Almost five years ago, I was pregnant with Petunia, and Basil and I had to begin understanding the world of baby gear. For the uninitiated, Planet Baby is quite a place. Vast warehouses full of plastic, wood and fabric (but mostly plastic) in varying shades of pastels and the occasional primary color, all with claims of necessity for a baby's health, happiness, ability to sleep, intelligence or edge in life. It is not hard for a young couple expecting their first child to end up drowning in baby stuff, much of it totally unnecessary. But there were some things that were musts. Unlike Sacajawea, we would be driving our baby home from the hospital, which meant that we needed a car seat. Seems simple, right? Wrong. Everything in Planet Baby is overwhelming, including the one thing you're required by law to have (if you plan to drive anywhere). There were different kinds of car seats, not to mention all the different brands and after-market accessories. Even the government doesn't recommend one kind or one brand - just making sure that any car seat you buy fits your car and is used correctly.
Our first choice was the kind of car seat - infant only or infant-toddler convertible. We assumed we'd go with the infant only seat, as it seemed de rigeur that babies only moved from place to place in those plastic buckets with the handles and sun shades. The books all said those would last the first year. But then on a trip to Great Beginnings to check out furniture on day, we saw a young couple there with their baby. They were looking at convertible car seats and explaining to the sales person, 'She's only five months old and she's already outgrown the infant seat!'
Basil and I exchanged shocked looks. Babies could outgrow the bucket seats before their first birthday!?! But those bucket seats were anywhere from $100 to $250! While their portability was attractive, their ability to damage my back and have a short-lived use was not. So we started exploring the idea of just using a convertible seat from the very beginning. After talking with a friend who had twins and had put them in convertible seats from the start, we became convinced that it was a possibility.
Basil and I set out to find the convertible seat with the highest height and weight limit out there. We wanted this thing to last for as long as possible, so we'd really get our money's worth (or someone else's money, if it were a gift) out of it. After testing some seats in our Saturn SL2, we settled on a Britax Marathon. Facing forward, it could safely handle kids up to 48 inches tall or 65 pounds. Petunia could conceivably ride in it until her fifth birthday.
Fast forward nearly five years, and Petunia is still in her Marathon. It's the only car seat we've ever owned, though we have washed it thoroughly a couple of times and moved the straps up as Petunia has grown. She is technically old enough (four and a half years tomorrow) and big enough (40 pounds, even) to move into a booster seat, but I am in no hurry.
Petunia is still small enough to fit into her Marathon, and she isn't complaining about riding in it. Basil and I don't have his and hers cars - we have two cars for the family, and we take turns driving them on different days. Whoever is driving Petunia gets the Ford Freestyle, where her car seat is installed, and whoever is not driving Petunia gets the Saturn. There's no moving the car seat back and forth. Also, unlike many families, we don't have a baby waiting for his/her turn in the convertible seat after outgrowing the infant seat.
I was thinking that we would move Petunia up to a booster seat early next month because we are flying to Chicago as a family, and I thought we would want something that would work on the plane and in the rental car. But the American Academy of Pediatrics doesn't recommend using boosters on planes, and it's easier just to rent a car seat from Avis with our car. For our trip to Orlando in June, we're taking the AutoTrain down and driving back. We know our Marathon fits fine in the Saturn, so we'll just use it on the way back.
Basil tells me that the time is soon coming for her to move into a booster, but I can't get super excited about it. I know that booster seats are safe for older, bigger kids, but it doesn't feel like graduation - it feels like a demotion (see page 2 of that link). I can't explain why I feel such a panic at the idea of moving Petunia into a booster. I'm not an especially hovery parent (at least, I don't think I am), letting my kid get some bumps and bruises along the road of life so long as there's no serious danger.
But for some reason, the car seat thing just freaks me out. Maybe it's that I remember the accidents I've been in throughout my life - getting broadsided on the passenger side by someone running a red light when I was about eighteen...being rear-ended while waiting to make a left-hand turn when I was about six...spinning my car around and riding the passenger-side wheels of my car down a retaining wall backwards (facing oncoming traffic) on I-71/75 when I was sixteen. Maybe it's because growing up I had a stepfather who was a police officer, and he would come home with these grisly stories of the accidents he had worked during his shift - severed limbs, a decapitation, gross manglings and deaths. Maybe it's because I have an alcoholic father who has been arrested for drinking and driving more than once, and I'm always amazed that he hasn't killed someone on the road.
If I could put Petunia in a big strong bubble to ride in the car for the rest of her life, I swear I'd do it, as long as she could hear the radio and see out the window. But I know that's not an option, and I know that her sturdy Marathon - always installed so it doesn't move so much as half an inch in any direction - will be retired to the garage sometime in the near future, as her shoulders will likely reach the top of the straps before the end of this year. (She has a long torso and is likely to outgrow the straps before she reaches 48 inches.) When the time comes, we'll get her a snazzy booster seat that can last several more years, but I'm not hoping that day comes anytime soon.